Compliance Assessment Summary Report: Newfoundland Multi-Foods Ltd.
For Funding Agreement no. 2021-HQ-000033 between Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada (CIRNAC) and Newfoundland Multi-Foods Ltd.
Name: Newfoundland Multi-Foods Ltd.
Location: desk audit
Time period covered by audit: April 1, 2021, until March 31, 2024
Total amount of CIRNAC funding received for this period: $944,598
Context
At the request of the Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada (CIRNAC), Samson & Associés CPA / Consultation Inc. performed a desk compliance assessment of the Funding Agreement between Nutrition North Canada (NNC or the 'Program') and Newfoundland Multi-Foods Ltd. (Recipient). Nutrition North Canada is a Government of Canada Program that helps make nutritious food and some essential items more affordable and more accessible to northern communities. The purpose of the assessment, in accordance with our engagement with NNC, was to provide information on:
- Whether the Recipient is passing on the full value of the subsidy to consumers;
- Whether the amounts disbursed to the Recipient through the fiscal years 2021–2022 through 2023–2024 were appropriately claimed in compliance with the Terms and Conditions of the Recipient's Funding Agreement;
- Whether program visibility requirements are met and that the subsidy is transparent to consumers;
- The Recipient's reporting and claiming systems and procedures with regard to gaps and controls issues; and
- Whether the Recipient respected program rules in regard to sales to ineligible clients.
The period covered by the compliance assessment is from April 1, 2021, until March 31, 2024. We determined our sample size by applying professional judgement based on the frequency of claims and the number of items in each claim.
The compliance assessment was performed as a desk audit. As a result, our interviews were performed based on electronic communication with the Recipient to identify and document their key control activities, their procedures and processes related to the claim of funds to NNC, program delivery and reporting. Therefore, we were unable to verify the accuracy of the weighting system used by the Recipient.
We subsequently performed detailed audit procedures on the accuracy and validity of the Recipient's claims and on the margin earned by the Recipient on the subsidized products.
Based on the procedures performed and as more fully described in our report, we did not find any significant deviations in the samples we selected; however, we identified improvements in the form of recommendations to improve the Recipient's control environment in relation to the Program.
Conclusions
Overall, we are of the opinion that the funding provided to the Recipient was spent for the intended purposes and in compliance with the terms and conditions for the 2021–2022 to 2023–2024 Funding Agreements signed with the Department. However, findings and recommendations under Section 1.2 were identified and should be read in conjunction with these conclusions.
- Except for the errors noted under Section 5.1, we can confirm that the amounts disbursed to the Recipient over three fiscal years (2021–2022 – 2023–2024) were appropriately claimed in compliance with the terms and conditions of the Recipient's Funding Agreement. Furthermore, the subsidy claimed for reimbursement by the Recipient relates to the type and nature of eligible cost requirements of the Program.
- Our review identified that the Recipient sold products to a Third-Party Retailer (TPR). Based on our sample of the Third-Party Retailer, we noted that the NNC subsidy was not reflected on customer sales receipts and that NNC signage was not present in the store.
- Based on discussions with the Recipient, they are aware of the requirements preventing the sale of subsidized products to ineligible businesses and establishments and the review did not find any sales to ineligible businesses.
- The Recipient is using the most effective and cost-effective supply chain arrangements and routes.
- The Recipient's database is appropriately coded.
- In our opinion, the Recipient and Third-Party Retailer passed on the subsidy to eligible clients and the value of the subsidy is not being eroded by the Recipient's profit margin practices.
- Three recommendations were identified to improve the Recipient's management systems, processes and practices in order to address the deficiencies noted.
The table below summarizes the recommendations identified by the auditor, the actioned measures required to be undertaken by the retailer/supplier, and their status.
| Auditors Recommendations for Newfoundland Multi-Foods Ltd. | Action Plan for Newfoundland Multi-Foods Ltd. | Status |
|---|---|---|
| The Recipient should implement a reconciliation between products listed on sale invoices and the amounts claimed under the program to ensure claim accuracy and that subsidies are properly passed on to clients. | After reviewing the management letter, the Recipient will speak to the invoice clerks to make certain that he / she checks the invoices, to make sure it is accurate as possible and make certain the appropriate subsidy is passed on. | Complete |
| The Recipient should strengthen its documentation and verification procedures by ensuring that the weight claimed in the compiled shipment report is reconciled to the corresponding waybill. | After reviewing the management letter, the Recipient has put checks and balances in place that hopefully protects us from that happening in the future, all shipments are double-checked before they ship. | Complete |
| The Recipient should ensure that Third-Party Retailers clearly indicate the NNC subsidy on customer sales receipts and display appropriate NNC signage in stores to demonstrate that the full subsidy is being passed on to consumers and that the Program is visible to residents of eligible isolated communities. | After reviewing the management letter, the Recipient will periodically ask our customer if they require more of the NNC signage to try and keep the importance of the NNC subsidies front and center and Multi Foods will send an email to remind the Third-Party Retailer of the visibility requirement on the customer purchase receipts as stated on the signed contract. | Complete |